What to Consider When Replacing an Existing Fence

Depending upon the type of materials used or their age, sometimes a homeowner needs to replace a fence.  Wood fences, in particular, can last a long time; yet unlike vinyl or aluminum, wood fences may eventually require replacement after decades’ worth of service.

In some cases, there’s a need to replace a fence when it’s not properly installed or inferior materials are used to build the original fence.  Not all wood is created equal and if you buy a lower grade piece of wood to build a fence, chances are you will be replacing fence panels sooner than when you deal with a company that stands behind a warranty for a certain number of years.  This is also true of chain link and certain styles of aluminum fence. 

tree in old garden by cloudy winter day.
Image credit: DollarPhotoClub (used under license).

Sometimes there’s also a need to replace a fence due to weather activity—in recent years we’ve seen some fences get destroyed by high winds during thunderstorms or when hurricanes pass through.

But no matter the situation, when it’s time to replace an old fence, there are some important things to think about:

Property Considerations Before You Replace a Fence

Check Your Local Zoning Laws

Perhaps the most important thing to consider before replacing a fence is to check your local zoning laws to see if you need a permit to replace an existing fence.  Even if you plan to use the same materials and replace the fence with the exact same height; you may still need to get a permit prior to installation.  The biggest mistake homeowners often make is replacing a fence without checking their local jurisdiction and end up spending a fortune in fees due to incorrect assumptions.  The same is true for those homeowners who need to adhere to guidelines from their local Homeowner’s Association (HOA)—always look at your guidelines to see if you need to get written approval before replacing a fence.

When you replace a fence, it’s also a good time to see if the existing fence is set on your property line. Sometimes a fence gets installed that falls short of your property line so a good time to correct that is when you install a replacement fence.  Likewise, if you find out that your current fence goes beyond your property line, a good time to rectify that situation is when you get a fence replacement installed.

Call Miss Utility Before You Replace a Fence

Even though you plan to replace a fence in the exact same spot as before, always call Miss Utility before you dig!  You never want to run the risk of hitting pipes or wires underground, even if your fence posts will go in the exact same area as before.  We’ve seen homeowners who are not the original owners make this mistake several times—they attempt to replace a fence on their own and run into big problems when they dig a new post hole that goes a few inches deeper than the original ones.  Trust me, this is a problem you don’t want to have!

Purchasing Considerations Before You Replace a Fence

Material Considerations

When there’s a need to replace a fence, we encourage you to look at the materials of your original fence, especially if you need to replace a wood fence due to rotting.  Make sure you find out the type of wood used.  As we’ve said before, not all grades and types of wood are created equal.  If you’re going to replace wood fences, we tend to work with western red cedar, pressure-treated southern yellow pine, oak and black locust as these are among the best quality materials for wood fences and are also low-maintenance.

Image Credit: ©2014 Frederick Fence Co. All rights reserved.
Image Credit: ©2014 Frederick Fence Co. All rights reserved.

If your goal is to replace your fence just once and never have to worry about it again, you may want to explore a higher grade of material such as ornamental aluminum or vinyl. We also have more information here about Replacing A Fence.

Think Long Term When You Replace a Fence

When you need to replace a fence, it’s a good time to ask why you need the replacement fence in the first place.  Sometimes when you buy a home with an existing fence, the original homeowner had a set of needs that may not match your present ones.  For example, if you need to replace a three-foot tall picket fence and you now plan to have children and pets, you may want to replace that fence with something taller and a bit sturdier to protect your children and keep your animals safe inside your yard.  Likewise, if you plan to install a pool in the yard, you may need to change where the fence goes based on local pool code.

If you’re a replacing an existing fence because you want more privacy, you may want to use the same materials but opt for a different style of panels so that you can freely enjoy your back yard without being in your neighbors’ line of sight all the time.

Ready to Replace Your Fence?

Have an existing fence that needs replacing?  Contact us today and one of our knowledgeable design experts will come out and give you a quote for getting a replacement fence.  We can also tear out and haul your existing fence away as part of the project!

Do you happen to own the ugliest fence in town that needs replacing?  Let us know and we’ll be happy to share the “before” and “after” photos when you install your replacement fence!